Updated!: To Fake Up or Not to Fake Up?

So I promised a second beauty blog, and here it is! This is my comparison between Benefit’s FakeUp and YSL’s Touche Eclat.

This month Benefit launched their new FakeUp concealer as part of their Spring’13 range. What they say:

This hydrating crease-control concealer – with Vitamin E & apple seed extract – hides dark circles & diffuses fine lines for a silky smooth, ultra-natural look.

A Touche Eclat user for the past 13 years or so, I was a lot younger when I started using it and I’ve since noticed that the concealer sits in the fine lines I now have under my eyes. It makes me look tired and haggard just minutes after I’ve put it on. Now I will say I never wear foundation or powder, I only wear concealer, so the coverage I get is very light. I have the world’s darkest circles under my eyes but my skin is fine and likes the breathe, thank you very much.

So I trotted off to the Benefit counter. I was matched to the Light shade (surprise surprise) There’s only 3 shades (Light, Medium and Deep). The price is £18.50 which might seem steep but when Touche Eclat is £23 a pop, it’s actually a potential saving!

So here goes:


The packaging is pretty, and would be easy to pop into a makeup back or handbag. It looks a little like those lipsticks you can get and has the hydrating balm around the edges and the concealer in the centre.

I started off with the FakeUp and just put it onto one eye so you could see what I look like without and with (it’s a bit scary, so be warned….)

FakeUp on left and nothing on right (sexy 'eh?)
FakeUp on left and nothing on right (sexy ‘eh?)

It’s obvious which has the make up on 😀 It was fairly easy to apply, though I think I have to get used to blending it because it still feels a little slippy due to the amount of balm. I found myself dabbing my finger into the centre of the stick to get more concealer than balm. I applied it straight from the stick onto my face and then smooshed it (official term) with my finger.

Next I applied Touche Eclat to the other eye. This is easy to apply. Just click the end and paint it on with the brush. Then pat with the middle finger to blend it in.

Touche Eclat on right eye (my left) FakeUp on left (my right)
Touche Eclat on right eye (my left) FakeUp on left (my right)

You can see there’s not a huge amount of difference. Though if you look closely you can see lines on the right side and it looks a tad dryer. The left side looks hydrated and plump. I took this photo with a window right in front of me and even light on both sides.

The final test I did was the face rub. I love to rub my face but with Touche Eclat I find that so much makeup comes off. So I gave both sides a good old scrub.

Top finger Touche Eclat, bottom finger FakeUp
Top finger Touche Eclat, bottom finger FakeUp

As you can see, make up came off from both products – which was expected. But can you see how shiny the bottom finger is? This is from the FakeUp balm. I’m not sure I like how shiny it comes off. Other bloggers have said that it sets to a satin finish but I’m not sure how satin I want my face to be! Anyway, it was obvious that I’d rubbed both eyes, so I might avoid doing that!

I removed both products using a Nivea face wipe. Touching my face afterwards, the eye that the FakeUp was on felt hydrated a smooth and more plump. The Touche Eclat eye felt smooth but dry. The Benefit FakeUp definitely seemed to treat my skin.

So what’s the verdict? I think I need to use the FakeUp a bit more to get used to applying it, because I’m a bit of a make-up dunce. But I’m pleased with the overall effect. I just worry it might make me look a little greasy in the summer. It’s cheaper than Touche Eclat and definitely hydrating.

Have you used this product yet? I’d love to hear what you think!


01/05/13: Update! So, I’ve worn FakeUp a few times over the last few weeks and the verdict is – YSL is better! The FakeUp coverage is far too sheer for my deep dark circles and I actually found it creased worse than Touche Eclat. So I’m sticking to good old faithful!
Follow on Bloglovin

2 thoughts on “Updated!: To Fake Up or Not to Fake Up?

  1. Hmm, I might have to give the Benefit Fake Up a try. I don’t have deep circles but I do have dark circles under my eyes and it makes such a difference when I cover them up!

    This post made me realize that I had a sample of Touche Eclat in my makeup drawer so I’ve been using it. It definitely helps, but I agree that it does seem to settle into noticeable lines after a short while! Definitely not the look I’m going for.

    I often use a bb cream or beauty balm when I’m going out and they help a lot with the dark circles. I hate putting it on all over my face all the time though. Even though it’s better than a lot of makeups, it still feels sticky. Maybe I’ll try it just under my eyes and see how that goes!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.